Julien Benda’s classic study of s Europe resonates today. The “treason of the intellectuals” is a phrase that evokes much but is inherently ambiguous. Other articles where The Treason of the Intellectuals is discussed: Julien Benda: La Trahison des clercs (; The Treason of the Intellectuals; also published . Treason of the Intellectuals (). When Machiavelli advises the Prince to carry out the Machiavellian scheme of action, he invests those actions with no.
|Published (Last):||26 December 2009|
|PDF File Size:||17.78 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||9.66 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
But those ideals, he argued, had been lost.
Selected pages Title Page. I feel this book leaves its arguments vaguely unfinished, and instead rests its case on historical failures and predictions, such julien benda treason of the intellectuals grand wars, which could have been explained away by other means, and often were.
Even though the first edition of this book was inwhich can seem ancient, but the main issues that it adresses are still alive today, and are still a problem. And too many scholars seem prepared to support the new dispensation. Sep 27, Wahyu Krisyanto rated it really liked it Shelves: Nothing seems to me more doubtful than Aristotle’s remark that it is probable the arts and philosophy have thw times been hulien and several times lost.
In the first case the “clerk” is despised by the just man, who denounces him as cunning and strikes him out of julien benda treason of the intellectuals rank of “clerk”; and in the second case he collapses under the hooting of the nations who call him inefficient, while he provokes a violent and loudly acclaimed reaction on the part of the realist, which is what is now happening in Italy. Hammam Azar rated it really liked it Dec 20, And this brings us to the question of freedom.
Not that the political Right, or even politics generally, have a monopoly on intellectual hypocrisy.
The Treason of the Intellectuals by Julien Benda
I intellectials also a word to say about the severities of these “justiciaries” towards France’s attitude immediately after her victory, towards her desire to force the enemy to make good the damage done to her, and to seize on pledges if he refused. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. The attitude of the Italian Fascists and the Russian Bolshevists towards their enemies is not calculated to give me the julien benda treason of the intellectuals here.
It is Man, and not the nation or the class, whom Nietzsche, Sorel, Bersgon extol in his genius for making himself master of the world.
From the time of the pre-Socratics, intellectuals, considered in their role as intellectuals, julein been a breed apart. When the distinction between culture and entertainment is obliterated, high art is orphaned, exiled from the only context in julien benda treason of the intellectuals its distinctive meaning can manifest itself: Human aspirations, julien benda treason of the intellectuals after power, would become the sole end of society.
Only as I matured did I realise that what we were julen was letting someone else – particularly if they had deep pockets – define what constituted a significant social problem. The process of disintegration has lately become an explicit attack on culture.
Mark rated it really liked it Oct 26, The cause of peace, which is julien benda treason of the intellectuals surrounded with adverse factors, in our days has one more against it—the pacifism which pretends to be scientific. Notice that the pacifism of the Church, at least among the great teachers, is not at all inspired by sentimental considerations, but by pure moral educations. Views Read Edit View history.
What has been said here, if it were not a work of history, could have been argued in all of 20 pages. This remark may be put in another form. Who – if not intellectuals? Historically, the Enlightenment arose as a deeply anti-clerical and, perforce, anti-traditional movement.
As regards the nation, think of Italy; as julien benda treason of the intellectuals class, think of Russia; and you will see the hitherto known point of perfection attained by the spirit of hatred against what is “different” among a group of men, consciously realist and at last liberated from all non-practical morality. Benda intellectuaps now best remembered for his short book La Trahison des Clercsa work of considerable influence.
To ask other readers questions about The Treason of the Intellectualsplease sign up. Trivia About The Treason of th I can imagine both priding julien benda treason of the intellectuals on getting free from a “stupid humanitarianism,” and finding disciples of Nietzsche and Sorel to praise them for it. Commercialisation of our talents in research and analysis did not make us any more relevant, just richer.
The treason of the intellectuals & “The Undoing of Thought”
In describing this process of leveling, Finkielkraut distinguishes between those who wish to obliterate distinctions in the name of politics and those who do so out of a treasn of narcissism. What Benda found novel was the accreditation of such cynicism by intellectuals. I wonder whether humanity, by adopting this system to-day, has not discovered its true law of existence and adopted the true scale of values demanded by its essence?
Still, there is something respectable about pointing this out, and it would seem to me that in a modern world, this is the kind of argument that is often offered in opposition to scientifically and ethically relativist postmodernist propositions.
In doing so, they justified and magnified political passions. However, there is a slight oddity in that the very julien benda treason of the intellectuals of the book seems to fail at its juliej julien benda treason of the intellectuals. The “treason” of which Benda writes is the betrayal by the intellectuals of their unique vocation.
And History will smile to think that this is the species for which Socrates and Jesus Christ died. The diatribe that Horkheimer and Adorno mounted against the concept of Enlightenment reminds us of an important peculiarity about the history of Enlightenment: